 |
eSCM ASSESSMENT
STANDARD v1.0
The maturity scale
The following matrix summarises
the key criteria
and their relevance for each rating in the maturity
scale:
 |
 |
 |
 |
The above is
for external customers. The same matrix is
applicable for internal customers with one
exception: |
 |
 |
Even
if the supply chain partners are communicating
on the same systems (e.g. SAP to SAP),
considered to be proprietary, they would
be given a rating of 400. When they
are on different systems, but are using
a middleware, this would get a rating
of 400 |
|
 |
All conditions of a certain
level has to be fulfilled - else the score
will default to the next lower level |
|
 |
 |
Definition
of limited, significant and minimum |
 |
 |
Limited:
from 25% to 50% of revenue, purchase
spend, new product revenues, etc |
 |
Significant:
> 50% of revenue, purchase spend,
new product revenues, etc |
 |
Minimum:
at least 10% of revenue, purchase spend,
new product revenues, etc. |
|
|
Maturity scale and exceptions
Bulk of the questions adopt the
standard maturity scale stated
in the preceding pages. However there are a few exceptions
 |
 |
 |
 |
Questions which
follow a slightly different maturity scale
are: |
 |
 |
Source
(Q 47, 55, 63, 71, 80, 89)
How are the invoices received from your
suppliers? – standards are not
emphasised here |
 |
Source
(Q 48, 56, 64, 72, 81, 90)
How are instructions communicated to
bank for payment to suppliers? –
standards are not emphasised here |
 |
Source
(Q 95, 101)
If there are any requirements of payment
of duties and indirect taxes to customs
/ government agencies, how are they
done? – best practice is using
standing instructions with banks, fully
integrated |
 |
Make
(Q 111, 114)
How are the final drawings, specifications,
formulae, part programs shared with
the customers? - internet enabled documentation
management is the standard with different
maturities depending on extent of use |
|
|
 |
 |
 |
Deliver
(Q 123, 132, 145, 157, 163, 169)
How do you send invoice to customer
for payment? – standards not emphasised
here |
 |
Deliver
(Q 124, 133, 146, 158, 164, 170)
How do you receive communication on
payments received, from your bank? –
best practice is not fully integrated |
 |
Deliver
(Q 177, 184)
If there are any requirements of payment
of duties and indirect taxes to customs
/ government agencies, how are they
done? – best practice is using
standing instructions with banks, fully
integrated |
 |
Return
(Q 187)
How do you send credit note to customer
for rejection? – standards are
not emphasised here. |
|
|
|